Conflict Detection & Resolution
Spotting conflicts early and solving them with levels, headings, speed and direct routings.
A conflict is a situation where two aircraft, if nothing changes, will lose the required separation. An area controller's skill is seeing conflicts long before they happen – often 10 or 20 minutes ahead – and solving them with the smallest, simplest instruction.
1. Detecting conflicts
For every pair of aircraft ask two questions:
- Are they at, or will they pass through, the same level? If not, there is no conflict.
- If yes: will their paths come within the radar minimum (5 NM)?
- Crossing tracks: work out when each aircraft reaches the crossing point. If the times are less than about a minute apart (at airliner speeds), they will be too close.
- Same direction: a faster aircraft behind a slower one at the same level will catch up – check the speeds.
- Opposite direction: closing speeds of 900 kt or more – 15 NM is only one minute! Correct semicircular levels normally prevent these.
- Climbs and descents: a level change through another aircraft's level is the most common hidden conflict.
Use your tools: Aurora's predicted track lines (vectors), the range-and-bearing line and the conflict alert. But don't rely only on alerts – scan and think ahead.
2. Resolving conflicts: your toolbox
| Tool | Good for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Level | Almost everything; easy to see and keep | "Climb flight level three six zero" |
| Heading | Crossing conflicts, quick fixes | "Turn left heading zero six zero, for traffic" |
| Speed | Same-route spacing, small adjustments | "Maintain Mach decimal seven eight" |
| Direct routing | Moving one aircraft away from the crossing point | "Proceed direct LATEB" |
At cruise, speed control uses Mach numbers: on the same route, giving both aircraft the same Mach keeps their spacing constant.
3. Choosing the right solution
- Simple: one instruction to one aircraft is better than several to both.
- Early: a 10° turn 50 NM before the crossing is enough; at 10 NM you need 60°.
- Positive: the solution must work even if the pilot is slow to react. Don't plan for exactly 5 NM – plan for 7 or 8.
- Pilot-friendly: prefer what the pilot wants anyway (a requested level, a direct) to a vector off route.
- Follow through: when the conflict is past, bring the aircraft back: "resume own navigation direct DAKAP", "climb flight level three eight zero, as requested."
4. When it goes wrong
If separation is about to be lost, give clear, urgent instructions with the reason and traffic:
"Levant two one eight, turn right immediately heading one two zero, traffic twelve o'clock, eight miles, opposite direction, same level."
If an aircraft reports a TCAS RA (resolution advisory), the pilot follows the TCAS, not you. Do not give instructions that contradict it; acknowledge and give traffic information until they report "clear of conflict".
5. Worked example
LVT218 eastbound on an airway at FL350, 480 kt ground speed, is 60 NM from point DAKAP. IAW124 northbound at FL350, 420 kt, is 53 NM from DAKAP. Times to DAKAP: LVT218 = 60 ÷ 480 × 60 = 7.5 min; IAW124 = 53 ÷ 420 × 60 = 7.6 min. They will reach DAKAP within seconds of each other: a conflict. Simplest solution, chosen early: change one aircraft's level to another valid level for its direction, e.g. "Iraqi one two four, climb flight level three seven zero." Done – 2,000 ft, no vectors needed. If the level is not available, a 20° turn for one of them now gives the 5 NM easily.
Controlling it at Levant
During Levant group flights many aircraft fly the same route at similar speeds. Assign different levels to aircraft that will follow each other on the same airway, or give the same Mach and check the spacing stays above 5 NM.
Check yourself
- What are the two questions for detecting a conflict? Same level (or passing through it)? Will they come within the minimum?
- Why is an early, small heading change better than a late, large one? It solves the conflict with less deviation and more margin.
- A pilot reports "TCAS RA". What do you do? Don't contradict it; acknowledge, give traffic information, wait for "clear of conflict".
- Two aircraft on the same route and level: how can you keep the spacing constant? Give them the same Mach number.
Simulation training material based on ICAO Doc 4444. Waypoints and callsigns in the example are fictitious.